Pangolin Finished and Thoughts on Competition Painting

20 thoughts on “Pangolin Finished and Thoughts on Competition Painting”

  1. I had done some research into the pangolins several posts before as I had really hadn’t heard about them before, as you stated, what a sad and pointless abuse of a animal.

    I didn’t realize how big your project was until you posted the comparisons today, I don’t think that would even fit on my painting table! Your dad will be very proud to have that as a gift and the effort you put into it!

    Your resolve to try something new and improve on untested methods outweigh any results in the competition, I always felt the personal best was the biggest award in any sporting competition like swimming.

    Liked by 3 people

    1. That means a lot to hear that you got interested in them because of this project. Its sad but because pangolins are only in two zoos in the US currently, from what I can tell, not that many people know of them. I hope that changes and their situation improves rapidly.

      The pangolin is so big, I couldn’t use my wet palette and I had to actually set the thing on my lap to paint it. At first I was struggling with how to hold it but as time when on, I got better at it fortunately.

      And thank you for the kind words! I figure trying new things is the best way to keep the hobby interesting and there’s always more to learn. That is what keeps me around as much as anything I’d say.

      Like

  2. That’s fantastic! Completely agree with you re the pangolin (this is a subject near to my own heart so I’ll refrain from writing a ten page rant, suffice to say “well done” to your dad, a very good cause, and a big happy birthday to him as well). Beautifully painted as well of course!

    Liked by 4 people

  3. Quite a varied update, Jeff, so I’ve taken my time going through it!

    The pangolin is excellent! 🙂  The base really does look good as well!  A very nice present for your dad to be sure.  A brilliant sculpt by Dave and a brilliant paint job by yourself!

    If I was to be honest, I’d never be able to judge minis in a competition!  Once the standard is above a certain level I can’t really distinguish and it would end up with thinking “do I like the colours” and “do I like the mini itself”.  So, at the end of the day, it’s up to someone judging your work from their own viewpoint and it’s not personal (you need to be more like me maybe – I’m too dumb to be offended most of the time ;-)).  Personally, Minerva is to me probably my favourite of everything I’ve seen you paint!  I can also see the point of giving just about everyone an award to make people feel their efforts have been appreciated.  And, of course, you are your harshest critic!  Based on your comments on jealousy I’m assuming I should be criticising you for being able to paint better than me but if I did that I’d be criticising every blog I read, rather than enjoying them (which I do).  I’ve seen jealousy in action first hand and it’s not nice.

    I know what you mean about being introverted as well.  It took me years at work to gradually develop the self-confidence to learn to challenge things.  I can remember attending meetings as a graduate engineer and thinking “well that doesn’t sound right to me but I can’t challenge this knowledgeable person” only to find out after the meetings that other people thought the same way as me.

    As for historical wargamers, not all of them are nit-pickers!  I’m like you and would buy something if I like it – in fact there are no doubt small inaccuracies in a lot of models that we may never notice or be aware of.  And I read far more fantasy and sci-fi wargaming blogs than I do historical because I like seeing other peoples models.  As far as nit-picking at work is concerned I’ve had to do that officially when it’s been related to product safety!  Some people don’t agree with their pet projects being “criticised” but that’s never stopped me from using my training and experience to tell ‘em when something needs re-evaluating.  I’m not an expert by any means but I consider that I usually know enough to know that I don’t know enough.  But some people always consider that they must be right!

    Anyway, keep up with the painting and blogging but, above all, enjoy your hobby!

    Liked by 4 people

    1. Thank you for giving it a read, John. I was a bit all over the place to be sure.

      Thank you for your kind words on the pangolin. I’m glad you like the final results!

      I think being a judge would be hard and it is a thankless job. You can’t make hundreds of decisions about entries and keep everyone happy. While I wouldn’t mind knowing more about why Minerva got Silver, I can’t fault their decision too much. I still really like her and am proud of her. I’ll happily show her off in my house for many years to come, I’m sure. You are spot-on about jealousy. Its easy to fall into that trap and social media makes it worse too but that’s a whole different topic that could probably be a post all on its own.

      I’m glad to hear I’m not the only introvert in our blogging community as well. It is hard to speak up and I will do it when its necessary but I find that I don’t like to put a lot of energy into putting myself out there when it comes to making friends in “real life” because about 8 or 9 times out of 10, I’m disappointed by the result, unfortunately. Again, that is going far afield from our hobby so I’ll leave it there!

      There are definitely good people in the historical side of the hobby and I think its a shame that a few people are so vocal about correcting mistakes. I do think that some people do a poor job of sharing information on historical inaccuracies too. A gentle hand never goes amiss, you could say. That is something you manage very well and your politeness is always appreciated! I do think one day I will paint some historical miniatures but for now, I still find it a bit intimidating and I’m not sure how to make sure that I don’t offend any of the “purists” out there. I guess sticking to what you know well is helpful in that regard.

      And no worries about the hobby. I will have fun and get my vindication along the way, I imagine 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  4. As with your post I’ll start with the positive, the Pangolin is excellent, stunning work on the face it’s sublime, I’m sure your dad will appreciate all your hard work in bringing this model to life mate, and a good challenge for your painting journey.

    Onto the negative side, competitions can be a positive, and a negative all at the same time, yes you can put in 500 hours on a single model, and then someone who put’s in only 50 hours wins the trophy, why because art is subjective, what one person likes another may loathe, let me give you an example, Jackson Pollack or Picasso are well renowned in the art world, personally I can’t stand there work, am I right or wrong neither, as that is my personal taste. This is the biggest thing in competitions, the judges are human, and they will have their own tastes on what is good or not.

    Minerva, was your first go at a 75mm model, and painting larger models, is a whole new skill set, and you learned a lot from this one, yes you have had a few set backs on the busts, but now is the time to pick yourself up, and decide what’s next, and use all the knowledge you’ve already learnt from your trial and error (you learn more from mistakes by the way) and find the next project, find what really speaks to you, as that is a big part of any project, enthusiasm for the subject.

    Not all Historical people are like that, John is a prime example, he has a vast knowledge on multiple wars and the participating armies, but I wouldn’t call him a button counter, as he will adapt models from other theatres of war to suit what he is looking for.

    Last one I promise, there are a lot of cliques in the competition painting scene, and they can be downright mean about other peoples work with their comments, especially if that person places above them, but as I said earlier it’s all subjective to a persons point of view. Just remember at the end of the day this is a hobby, and you should be enjoying your part in it, not bringing in more stress into a part of life that is supposed to be fun !

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Thank you for the kind words, Dave, and for all the green stuff as well! 😀 I think my Dad, who shares your namesake, will like it too.

      You described painting competitions well. I would urge anyone painting to avoid thinking about their entries in terms of hours spent and just enjoy painting them as well as they possibly can. That is my approach and it has mostly served me well. I certainly have avoided the kind of meltdowns that I mentioned in this post, if nothing else.

      I agree with you on Minerva and I am still proud of her, much like I still really like the stuff I entered at Golden Demon. It is a shame that hobbying hasn’t gone as well as I would like this year with the failed busts and then painting stuff for two games I don’t like but that’s the way it goes sometimes. I’m contemplating the next display project right now and will resume the journey of getting better at larger scale miniatures in fairly short order. This year’s show gave me plenty of motivation to do that, even if I don’t think it was intended.

      Thankfully only a small number of historical fans are that bad but it is something you see that can be both grating and a turn-off from that side of the hobby sadly. If only we had a few more John’s to balance it out!

      Unfortunately, I agree with you on cliques. I feel like Golden Demon has that but even worse but I’ve only entered once so maybe I’m wrong. No matter where it is, I’m on the outside of that stuff by choice and I don’t want to bring other people down in the hobby either. As you said, some people paint things that I don’t really think are that great but we all have different taste and that’s okay. The best thing you can do is focus on getting better and trying to learn new things which is what I will do for the foreseeable future. Onwards and upwards, as they say!

      Liked by 2 people

  5. well the giant pangolin looks s as amazing to me. I hope he likes it. Great job.

    sorry the painting competition wasn’t as fun as you hoped. I feel any event that is judged (painting, figure skating) suffers from the feelings of I ought to have scored higher more easily than one that are scored (tournament, baseball). It’s not so much because it’s a competition but bc do much of it is based in subjective tastes and intangible qualities.

    though I applaud you for trying out new techniques instead of the old stand bys. In the long term, that breadth will only improve the overall ability.

    button counters are a small vocal minority in historical gammers.
    I once played with a guy who was new to historicals and WWII and showed up with his tanks painted blue. I of course said something along the lines of “these are your tanks so do what you want but German tanks were not blue but this kinda yellow color.” He was cool with it. He only got exasperated when he was told it for the 10 time that night bc everyone who wandered up to the table said “why are those tanks blue. They weren’t blue.”

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Thank you for the kind words as always! It was a bummer that this year’s event wasn’t as good for me personally as the previous. There is a saying that I can’t remember exactly but the spirit of it is: “Don’t enter into a painting competition unless you can handle any result you might get” and I think maybe I should have heeded that in hindsight. If I did my very best, then I think I would have accepted the results even more than I did, if that makes any sense.

      Regardless, I think you’d be a fun painting judge to shadow. I can only imagine what kind of comments you’d utter while doing your job haha!

      That is a funny but also kind of discouraging story. I hope that didn’t put him off the hobby! I can’t help but think of how the same situation would be received in LOTR. If you painted a Uruk-Hai and didn’t get the reddish-brown skin tone right, how would you feel if everyone at a tournament told you that? You wouldn’t feel like people wanted you to participate in that community, in addition to thinking that everyone was a little petty. Obviously, that is very unlikely to happen but if its absurd in LOTR, why would it be okay for some in historicals? I guess accuracy trumps all for some people but even with that, I think keeping criticism to yourself would go a long way towards making new people want to stick around.

      Like

  6. This was a really great post Jeff. For one, I can hardly think of a more beautiful gift for your father. A truly beautiful piece that you’ve painted exquisitely.

    As for the painting competition, you have some good insights on it. I absolutely love your Hobbit / wolf diorama. It really captures Tolkien’s writing and creations beautifully and so flavourfully.

    You are easily and most definitely a Gold level painter, but events like this with just 2 of your entries are always just snapshots in time and space. There could be all kinds of reasons for why you got Silver this year, but that doesn’t mean that your skills have suddenly downgraded, it just means that for whatever reason based on these 2 entries at this moment in time at that space in time a few people made a certain judgment.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. You’re too kind and thank you for reading it! I’m a week away from giving my Dad his gift so we’ll see what he thinks very soon.

      I also appreciate your thoughts on the competition. You make several good points and you’re probably more right about it than the way that I chose to take receiving silver. Entering in painting competitions is a real ego check and it certainly took me down a notch! 🙂

      Like

  7. A huge post with really three aspects to discuss (or two, actually!)

    Love the Pangolin – the paint has come up amazinglky well, and being a commission from Dave also makes it even more special as a totally unique piece. I mean, technically every miniature we all paint are unique pieces due to our unique paintjobs, but this is obviously a big step beyond that with a wonderful unique sculpt from Dave and a paintjob that enhances it even more. It’s also one big impressive model! The scale shots really show how big it is, which is something that would be totally missed if they were not there!

    On historicals – there’s really two aspects to it, and I can appreciate both. The “rivet counters” (as they’re called) actually do provide a valuable “service” of sorts in that they point out things that are inaccurate or one-offs or the like. Without them pointing things out, you can end up with really inaccurate things happening or being shown/depicted that start to be taken as accurate or truth.

    A good example would be Assassins Creed Shadows – even without discussing Yasuke at all, they showed videos featuring Chinese architecture in Feudal Japan, the wrong plants for the season depicted, banners cut incorrectly, non-historical banners taken from renenactors… and so on – all while touting their “historical accuracy” in their promo media.

    The problem occurs in the intersection between “I’m making a cool thing” and “I’m being accurate to history” – the intent of the artists or creators and how they present their work – and then how those with knowledge discuss those inaccuracies with others. Awhile back, I had a guy email me to tell me that I’d gotten the pattern used on these tanks wrong, the issue with the reference photo, and what happened around all of that.

    https://azazelx.com/2022/04/19/battlefront-15mm-m4a1-sherman-armoured-squadron-reinforcements-british-8th-army-desert-rats-for-flames-of-war/

    He worded it in a “nice work, but…” manner that came across as a bit ..I’ll say (not as an insult) autistic and said I can email him for the right patterns. If I were painting my FoW stuff as 100% accurate, then I’d have followed up and repainted, but since I’m using them as toy tanks on the table, I’m good with these tanks being a bit different and distinctive, if not entirely accurate.

    As for the Golden Demon and painting competitions in general… this is what made me take so long to comment on this post, but I think you’re approaching it from a fundamentally wrong starting place, which leads you down a similar path to people like Zumitko.

    I won’t go into it in typed form, since I don’t want it to come across as an attack whne it absoluitely is not – if we ever catch up for a chat on Discord or something like that I’d love to discuss it as it’s the sort of thing that’s more easily communicated with the back and forth of a verbal conversation. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks for the kind words on the pangolin! Dave definitely deserves his plaudits as well because it was fairly straightforward to paint thanks to his sculpting work.

      I can certainly see where you’re coming from on Historical miniatures and there are great opportunities where button counters’ knowledge can be invaluable. For me, it is still a strong turn off towards painting historical miniatures but they might be just as glad to not have me after this post to be fair! 🙂

      We can certainly chat on Discord or something similar in the future as well. I welcome constructive criticisms when I can get it and ultimately, my experience this year will make me a better painter too even if it was a bit like having to eat your vegetables this time around 🙂

      Like

  8. Firstly, I love that pangolin, it’s turned out way better than I could have expected considering that real pangolins tend to have rather drab colouration. I thought that the size contrast with Nuka Girl was also fun and wondered if the pangolin could make an appearance as a really huge critter in one of your Fallout games before heading off to your Dad?

    Getting that kind of feedback in your competition can be tough, especially in something that is somewhat subjective. Is there a clear rubric about what the judges are looking for in these competitions? Or can you get marked down just because your work isn’t to their taste? Anyway I definitely agree that the best revenge is a life lived well so I look forward to admiring whatever you’re inspired to work on next.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Cheers, mate! I had to do some research and find the most visually appealing pangolin for this project, truthfully. I’m glad you like the scale comparison pictures too. They were fun for me to shoot.

      There is a rubric though I don’t get to see the scores that I received. It seems to me like very few painting competitions actually share scores and feedback with the participants. I can certainly see where that might just spark more debate for the judges but even still, I’d like to see where the judges thought I could improve. My understanding is that they used a system where there were four judges and they dropped the lowest score this year so I don’t think there was a strong bias against me on their part.

      I’ve got plans and ideas for how to improve and go back and get another gold in the nearish future so I will certainly try and get some revenge 🙂

      Like

Leave a reply to Wudugast Cancel reply